Terrifying Discipline
  • Media Coverage and Resources
  • "A Terrifying Way to Discipline Children" - The Blog

PRESS AND MEDIA

.

Picture
"A Terrifying Way to Discipline Children"  by Bill Lichtenstein, New York Sunday Times, September 9, 2012. 


Picture

The basement closet in the Old Harrington School, in Lexington, Mass., which was used as an isolation/ seclusion room for children as young as 5 years-old.  Lexington Public Schools told the New York Times that it was a classroom for "one-on-one meetings between teachers and students . . . with good lighting." 


.

Picture
Vigil marks anniversary of Corey Foster's death at Leake & WattsTeen died at center while being restrained The Journal News (April 18, 2013) 

.

Picture
Marysville parent claims special ed student put in closet for 'timeout'  The Marysville Globe (April 23, 2013) 

.

Picture
March 16, 2013 Letter to New York Times Regarding "Terrifying Way to Discipline Children" Editor's Note 

.

Picture
Deadly Discipline? Students Hurt, Dying After Being Restrained ABC News Nightline  (11/29/12)

.

Picture
"His name is Bill and he is a fighter against restraints and seclusion."  Children's Mental Health Network (10/18/12) 

.

Picture
Sixth Grader Punished in Windowless Closet  NBC 10 Philadelphia(1/30/13) 

.

Picture
Children's Mental Health Network Highlights White House Petition to Support Keep All Students Safe Act.  Click here to sign the petition now!  Children's Mental Health Network (1/29/13)  





,

Picture
Special ed teacher suspended after school reviews shoving video  KENS-TV San Antonio, Texas (1/22/13) 

.

Picture
Mass. Sued over Allegedly Abused and Neglected Foster Children New England Cable News (1/22/13)

.

Picture
Seclusion And Restraint In Schools: Parents Fight Back Against Deadly Tactics Click here to sign the petition now.   Huffington Post (11/30/12)  

.

Picture
"NBC4 Takes You Inside A Seclusion Room" NBC25 Clio, MI (10/25/12) 


.

Picture
"Cameras In Classrooms? Bring It On!"  Kymberly Grosso (10/15/12) 


.

Picture
"Seclusion Rooms Expose Arizona's Lack of Regulations."  Channel 3 News, Glendale, AZ.  (10/18/12)

.

Picture
Report: Columbus School District Misused Seclusion Rooms  StateImpact/NPR (9/28/12)

.

Picture
Is Lexington Getting Over Its Special Education Saga?  Patrick Ball (10/10/12) 

.

Picture
"Still a Terrifying Way to Discipline Children: The Sunday New York Times Expose One Month Later"  Bill Lichtenstein  (10/7/12) 


The trailer for "Won't Back Down," a new movie with Maggie Gyllenhaal, Viola Davis, Rosie Perez and Holly Hunter.  The film reflects the situation in America's schools, from teaching kids with special needs, to the use of isolation rooms, to the struggle for transparency and accountability of school boards.

.

Picture
"Pine Tree says confining child not against law."  Sarah Thomas (9/30/12)  “I was walking to my daughter’s classroom, and I heard screaming, and it got closer as I was walking,” Abigail Alldredge said. “Then I saw two teachers holding a door shut, and I could hear a child screaming to be let out.”

.

Picture
"Three and four year olds in Texas locked in "Monster Closets" in school to get them to calm down.   KENS-TV, San Antonio (with video).

.

Picture
"Lexington School Committee responds to abuse allegations"  Hannah McGoldrick  (9/24/12)

.

Picture
"Elementary school faces lawsuit over padded seclusion room" (with video) KTVK-TV Phoenix, AZ  (9/18/12) 

.

Picture
"Special needs teen says he was abused in Lexington public schools: Says he was placed in isolation rooms "  WCVB-TV (9/19/12)

.

Picture
"Family brings new allegations of abuse in Lexington schools"  Hannah McGoldrick (9/19/12)


.

Picture
"Editor's Note by the New York Times"  Segment and Lichtenstein response. Greater Boston/Beat the Press (9/21/12) 

.

Picture
"Schools' use of seclusion rooms not against law, probe finds" Pressley Baird, Wilmington, NC  StarNews (9/17/12) 

.

Picture
"Harsh Penalties for Disruptive Students" New York Times Readers Respond to "A Terrifying Way to Discipline Children."  (9/16/12)

,

Picture
"In Seclusion Room Saga, LPS and Lichtenstein Read and React" Patrick Ball  (9/17/12) 

.

Picture
"Serious Child Abuse, Petty Concerns" Bill Lichtenstein (9/16/12)

.

Picture
"Time for a Time Out: Why Are 40,000 Children So Harshly Disciplined in Public Schools?"  Maia Szalavitz  (9/10/12)


.

Picture
NY Times Readers respond to "A Terrifying Way to Discipline Children" Sunday New York Times  (9/16/12) 

,

Picture
"New York Times acknowledges ‘disputed’ details in Lichtenstein op-ed" Ben Aaronson (9/18/12) 

,

Picture
"Readers Poll: 65% Concerned or Very Concerned About the Treatment of Special Needs Students in Lexington"  Lexington Minuteman (9/19/12)

,

Picture
Superintendent: Arlington 'Does Not Sanction the Use of Seclusion'  By John Waller (9/18/12)

,

Picture
"LPS Superintendent Statement Challenges NYT OpEd Alleging Mistreatment of Special Needs Student" Patrick Ball (9/10/12) 

,

Picture
NYT Admits Some Problems With Op-Ed  The Nation's Greg Mitchell (9/16/12)

.

Picture
"Kindergartener’s Mop Closet Restraint Yields School Settlement; Seclusion Is Still Used Elsewhere"  By Debra Cassens Weiss (9/11/12)

.

Picture
"Ash asks state to review claims of abuse in Lexington schools"  Hannah McGoldrick, (9/13/12)

.

Picture
"Lexington Schools Behold the Power of the New York Times" Eric Randall (9/13/12)

.

Picture
"New Developments in LPS Seclusion Room Saga" Patrick Ball (9/14/12)

.

Picture
Broadside: "Lexington Superindendent on the Defensive" (9/13/12)  

,

Picture
"Recapping the LPS "Seclusion Room" Controversy Thus Far" Patrick Ball (9/13/12) 

.

Picture
"Lexington schools chief asks for state review of time-out rooms" By Deirdre Fernandes (9/13/12)


.

Picture
"Lexington school head wants probe of time out rooms, Deidre Fernandes, (9/12/12)

.

Picture
The latest on the death of Corey Foster, as reported in the Sunday NY Times story on restraints and seclusion rooms in schools.  "Report offers new details in Leake & Watts death" The Journal News (9/11/12)

.

Picture
"Lexington parents call for investigation into 'seclusion rooms" Lexington Minuteman, Hannah McGoldrick (9/12/12)  



.

Picture
"Lexington special needs student locked in closet, lawsuit claims,"  John Atwater (9/12/12) 

.

Picture
"Special Needs Abuse in Lexington?"  Greater Boston 0/12/12

.

Picture
"Parents Demand Answers About Punishment At Lexington Schools"  (9/11/12) 

.

Picture
"Residents, School Committee Members Call for Independent Review of Isolation Room Complaints" Patrick Ball (9/11/12)


.

Picture
CBS News 4 WBZ: "Parents Outraged Over Use of Isolation Room" (9/11/12) 

.

Picture
"Superintendent denies use of 'seclusion rooms' in Lexington schools." Hannah McGoldrick (9/11/12)

.

Picture
"Parents want review of report kindergartner put in closet: Lexington official defends school" Boston Globe (9/12/12)

.

Picture
Nightmare in a Seclusion Room  The New York Sunday Times story, "A Terrifying Way to Discipline Children," sheds light on the problem of special needs students mainstreamed in schools that don't know how to care for them. (9/11/12)



.

Picture
Broadside: "Locked door punishment?"  (9/11/12) 

,

Picture
"Lichtenstein Responds to Ash's Statements" Patrick Ball (9/11/12) 

.

Picture
"Times says op-ed on Lexington schools had inaccuracies"  Deirdre Fernandes (9/11/13)

.

Picture
New England Cable News: Lichtenstein on Lexington Abuse Deanna Morgan (9/10/12)

.

Picture
"LPS Officials Will Respond to NY Times OpEd Alleging 'Terrifying' Treatment of Special Needs Student" Patrick Ball (9/10/12) 

.

Picture
Fox News 25: "Lexington parent: Seclusion rooms are torture, not suitable punishment"  Heather Hegedus (9/10/12)



.

Picture
"Lexington, Mass. father claims district mistreated his daughter" Deanna Morgan, New England Cable News (9/10/12)

.

Picture
U.S. Committee on Education and the Workforce: Seclusion and Restraint a 'Terrifying Way to Discipline Children" (9/10/12) 

.

Picture
"Controversy Over Isolation And Restraints In A Lexington Public School"  Radio Boston (9/11/12) 

.

Picture
"Never leave a child alone during a meltdown."  Claudia M Gold  (9/11/12) 

.

Picture
"Experts Call 'Scream Rooms' Untherapeutic, Harmful To Children And Others At School"  Kathy Megan, Hartford Courant, January 14, 2012

.

Picture
"Mom of autistic child found stuffed in duffle bag heads to board meeting with 170,000 signatures"   WHAS- TV News, Harrodsburg, Kentucky   (1/19/12) 

.

Picture
"Family Speaks Out about Abuse Investigation"  Meghan B. Kelly (10/1/09) 


Articles and Blogs

Kids Put in Solitary Confinement in Schools & Parents Have No Idea 
- The Stir

"Forum: Time-out booths aren't answer to bad behavior"  On-Line Athens (Ga.) Marilyn E. Gootman  May 14, 2002

Resources

.

Picture
U.S. House Committee on Education and the Workforce: Seclusion & Restraint Resource Page

.

Picture
U.S. Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions: Full Committee Hearing - Beyond Seclusion and Restraint: Creating Positive Learning Environments for All Students 

.

Picture
U.S. General Accounting Office: Report on Seclusion and Restraints: Selected Cases of Death and Abuse at Public and Private Schools and Treatment Centers

.

Picture
"U.S. Department of Education "Restraint and Seclusion Resource Document" (PDF Download) with introduction by U.S. Secretary of Education, Arne Duncan.  May 2012. 

.

Picture
"Cameras in the Classroom a Crusade for Parents of Special-Needs Kids" ABC News Christina Ng (9/5/12) 

.

Picture
"Applying International Human Rights Standards to the Restraint and Seclusion of Students with Disabilities" University of Minnesota Law School's  "Law and Inequality" Journal. (PDF Download)



Rose Lichtenstein Case

Click Below to Download Files from Rose L. v. Lexington Public Schools
rose_lichtenstein_documents.pdf
File Size: 6422 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

peoples_deposition_excerpt_9-4-08.pdf
File Size: 744 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

depo_-_peoples.pdf
File Size: 1850 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

n_peterson_deposition_on_time_out_rooms_9-2008..pdf
File Size: 124 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File



Photos of Seclusion Room at Harrington School, Lexington MA

These images were taken by Bill Lichtenstein and have been released under a license that allows free re-use for any purpose.

Lexington, Mass.  School Committee Hearings

Dr. Paul Ash, Lexington Superintendent of Schools, addresses Sunday New York Times story on restraints and seclusion at school board meeting, September 11, 2012 (click below to play): 

.

Picture
Lexington, MA School Committee Meeting LexMedia (9/11/2012) 




Contact Lichtenstein Creative Media: One Broadway; 14th Floor; Cambridge, MA  02142
 Tel: 617-682-3700 Fax: 617-682-3710  LCM@LCMedia.com